Basic Subject Matter of Report
Construction Contracts and Dispute Resolution.
Course Context
Masters Course in Quantity Surveying. Equally relevant to International Construction Project Management masters.
Report Requirements
- Draft a report to advise the Employer on the appropriateness of the manner they have adopted to resolve and/or manage their dispute with the Contractor.
- Recommend any suitable alternative(s) that could make the client successful in the dispute.
- The report should also critically analyse the suitability of any recommendations made, with authoritative explanation and justification.
Scenario
The Employer has contracted the Contractor to build the road network for their new housing development. The works contract also includes for the Contractor to design and install the street lighting complete with the necessary fittings and fixtures[A1] .
The two parties successfully negotiated and signed FIDIC’s Conditions of Contract for Construction for Building and Engineering Works designed by the Employer, Second Edition 2017[A2] , with no need to incorporate any modification in the Special Provisions[A3] .
Works started on site on Monday, 6th January 2020. And, the two contracting parties have cooperated amicably until when the Employer refused to pay in full July’s Interim Payment Certificate (IPC). They assert that the level of workmanship, for that part of the works around the junction where their sales offices are located, is substandard due to some key site personal needing to self-isolate as a result of the ongoing coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic[A4] , and that part was done by temporary staff who have not worked with the Contractor previously. Indeed, there were three weeks in July when there were no site activities[A5] . the Contractor is not happy about not receiving their full payment, and have been demanding it ever since.
The site had to close again in the first three weeks of September, as several more key staff were self-isolating. And, for this, the Contractor has this time put in a request for extension of time (EOT) citing this as ‘an exceptional circumstance’, and also asked for more money, as a result[A6] . Both requests were summarily rejected by the Employer on 5th October.
The Contractor is not at all happy and the two parties’ relationship has now deteriorated, as shown in the timeline of events:
- 6th October 2020: the Contractor wrote to the Employer giving its notice of intention to suspend the works, if they do not receive the full payment of July’s IPC. On that same date, they also issued their notice of their intention to terminate the contract, if they do not receive approval for their request for EOT and for more money that was summarily rejected on 5th October[A7] .
- 28th October 2020: without receiving the full payment, or the EOT and more money, the Contractor wrote to the Employer indicating they were terminating their contract, with immediate effect, and citing that the Employer has been failing to fulfil its contractual obligations[A8] .
- 29th October 2020: the Employer wrote to the Contractor, disputing the Contractor’s entitlement to terminate the contract and demanding that they return to site, or else they will terminate their contract[A9] .
- 13th November 2020: With the site still closed, and no word heard from the Contractor, the Employer wrote to the Contractor giving their notice to terminate the contract citing that the Contractor had abandoned the works and has showed no willingness to return to site and resume works. They also expressed their wish to deduct Delay Damages, recall the Performance Security and refer their dispute to adjudication[A10] [A11] .
- 16th November 2020: the Contractor wrote to the Employer contesting the Employer’s right to terminate the contract, and asked for it to be withdrawn to avoid escalating the matter to adjudication, as they believe this would provide them with a quicker route to grant them redress. They also contest the Employer’s rights to deduct Delay Damages and to recall the Performance Security[A12] .
30th November 2020: still at a stalemate, with none of the parties doing anything to amicably resolve their differences, the Employer has now approached your firm of consultants for advice. They wish to refer the dispute to a DAAB, whose members are yet to be appointed, as they found no need for them at the start with the very good working relationship the two parties enjoyed[A13] .
Key Concepts/Definitions in Scenario
IPC (Interim Payment Certificate): a concept created within the FIDIC standard form mentioned in the scenario. Essentially a request for payment issued by the Contractor in this case.
Special Provisions: a concept created within the FIDIC standard form mentioned in the scenario. These would supplement the standard form terms and conditions but, as the scenario sets out, are unused.
EOT (Extension of Time): a concept created within the FIDIC standard form mentioned in the scenario. A lever under the contract for the Contractor to move where its initial programme will be subject to delay; EOT isn’t an unconditional contractual right of course; rather, it can be levered only where certain circumstances and/or events have occurred.
Delay Damages: self-explanatory concept (commonly understood as liquidated damages) under the aforesaid standard form contract, pre-agreed amount(s) as a Employer’s remedy for delay.
Performance Security: again, under the contract, a lever or remedy for the Employer against the Contractor connected to its performance obligations/failure to discharge those.
DAAB (Dispute Avoidance and Adjudication): concept (board of people) created within aforesaid standard form. Disputes are referred to the DAAB and it issues binding decisions; it can also provide informal advice and assistance during the contract to the parties before a dispute crystallises (i.e. to avoid that). The DAAB’s actions can of course be undermined by a court, subject to the rest of the agreement in dispute.
FIDIC Contract Data
Sub-Clause | Data to be given | Data |
1.1.85…………… | Time for Completion: | 365 days |
1.4………….…… | contract shall be governed by the law of: | Scotland[A14] |
4.2…………..…… | Performance Security (as percentages of the Accepted Contract Amount in Currencies): percent: ……………………………………………………………………….. currency: ……………………………………………………………………… | 10 % Pound Sterling |
8.8…………. | Delay Damages payable for each day of delay………………………….. | £5,000.00 |
8.8…………. | maximum amount of Delay Damages …………………………………………… | £500,000.00 |
12.2…………. | method of measurement ………………………………………………………..……… | Bill of Quantities |
14.2…………. | total amount of Advance Payment (as a percentage of Accepted Contract Amount) ……………………………………………………… | 20 % |
14.2…………. | currency or currencies of Advance Payment …………………………… | Pound Sterling |
14.3(iii) ……… | percentage of retention ……………………….……………………………………. | Not Applicable % |
14.7(b)(i)……… | period for the Employer to make interim payments to the Contractor under Sub-Clause 14.6 …………….……………………………… | 28 days |
14.8………………. | financing charges for delayed payment (percentage points above the average bank short–term lending rate as referred to under sub-paragraph (a))…………………………………. | 2 % |
14.15……….. | currencies for payment of Contract Price: | Pound Sterling |
14.15(a)(i) ….. | proportions or amounts of Local and Foreign Currencies are: Local …………………………………………………………. Foreign ………………………………………………………. | £2,500,000.00 Not Applicable % |
21.2…………. | Appointing entity (official) for DAAB members ……………. | Association for Consultancy and Engineering (ACE) |
Referencing
Harvard.
Will expect case law in the main, references to FIDIC clauses, some legislation (e.g HGCRA Act ’96 as amend’d) and perhaps academic commentary (less of the latter).
Word Count Constraints
3500 – 4000 (max).
Apportionment of Marks
Element | Max. Mark |
Introduction | 10 |
Literature review / relevant background research | 50 |
Conclusions / Recommendations | 20 |
Referencing | 10 |
Structure / Grammar | 10 |
High-Level Thoughts on Report Approach
A few discrete issues seem to require dealing with:
- All the issues called out by the tracked comments, basically.
- Payments, timing of requests and communications.
- Housing Grants/Construction Act ’96 as amended in re adjudication referral rights and payments.
- What the particular FIDIC standard form used says generally as it touches on the issues (Conditions of Contract for Construction for Building and Engineering Works designed by the Employer, Second Edition 2017). Aka FIDIC Redbook.
- What the surrounding case law adds to the issues.
Potential Authorities
Case law:
- Al-Waddan Hotel Ltd v Man Enterprise SAL (Offshore) [2014] EWHC 4796 (TCC)
- Attorney General for the Falklands Islands v Gordon Forbes Construction (Falklands) Ltd (2003) 6 BLR 280
- Braes of Doune Wind Farm (Scotland) Ltd v Alfred McaLpine Business Services Ltd [2008] APP.L.R. 03/13
- Bremer Handelgesellschaft mbH v Vanden Avenne Izegem nv [1978] 2
- City Inn Ltd v Shepherd Construction Ltd (2010))
- DeBeers v. Atos Origins IT Services [2010]
- Doosan Babcock Ltd (formerly Doosan Babcock Energy Ltd) v Comercializadora de Equipos y Materiales Mabe Limitada (previously known as Mabe Chile Limitada) [2013] EWHC 3201 (TCC))
- Gaymark Investments PTY Limited vs Walter Construction Group Limited [1999] NTSC 143
- Motherwell Bridge Construction v Micafil Vakuumtechnik (2002) CILL 1913
- Multiplex Construction v Honeywell Control Systems
- Peak Construction (Liverpool) Ltd v McKinney Foundations Ltd (1970)
- Steria Ltd v Sigma Wireless Communications Ltd [2008] CILL 2544
- Walter Lilly & Co. Ltd. v Giles Patrick Cyril Mackay and DMW Developments Ltd. [2012] EWHC 1773 (TCC)
Literature/Reviews:
- Glover, J. (2008) FIDIC an overview: the latest developments, comparisons, claims and a look into the future. Fenwick Elliott.
- Hughes, W., Champion, R. and Murdoch, J. (2015) Construction contracts: law and management, fifth edition. Routledge.
- Tolson, S. & Glover, J. (2008) Time bars in construction and global claims. Fenwick Elliott.
- Turner & Townsend (n.d.) The FIDIC suite of contracts. Turner & Townsend. (http://www.turnerandtownsend.com/The_FIDIC_Suite_of_Contracts_Onkmq.pdf.file).
- http://fidic.org/Bookshop/about-Bookshop/which-fidic-contract-should-i-use
- http://www.isurv.com/site/scripts/documents_info.aspx?documentID=5245&categoryID=1091
Access to FIDIC Contract
Available for LexisPSL members; some extracts available online; swaths of the relevant provisions from the contract are available online/Google will pull them up.
Footnote
I’m looking for a report to benchmark my own against as obtaining a pass is critical for me on these modules; I have a good handle on the ask and will have my own report drafted in around ten days so can come-and-go with any questions etc.
[A1]Perhaps some brief coverage of appropriateness of the contract form used given two different projects (i.e. build the road network and, discretely, design and install the street lighting inc’ fixtures and fittings.
Can cover this quickly: contract is recommended for building or engineering works designed by the Employer’ or by his/her representative. This is usually, where the Contractor constructs the works as per a design provided by the Employer. Although, the works may involve some elements of civil, mechanical, electrical and/or construction works‘ that are designed by the Contractor. So probably not too unusual to use this standard form.
[A2]AKA Fidic Red Book / Conditions of Contract for Construction.
[A3]No special provisions (i.e. no bespoke terms added; just FIDIC standard form as published).
[A4]This assertion needs dealing with: quality of workmanship and contractual rights in that regard. Seems nonsensical: work can’t be substandard because of self-isolation, but it can be late/behind time.
[A5]This needs dealing with (temp’ staff with no pedigree).
[A6]Needs dealing with in terms of contract rights/case law etc.
[A7]Needs dealing with in terms of timings and rights under contract.
[A8]As above.
[A9]As above.
[A10]As above.
[A11]Refer to adjudication required consideration in terms of FIDIC terms and Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act (HGRA 96 as amended by the Local Democ’ (etc) Act 2009).
[A12]As above.
[A13]Comment on the DAAB wish of the employer required (recommend, don’t recommend and why). Advs/Disadvs of dispute boards, adjudication etc.
[A14]Scots law in play. Not profoundly significant as much case law and legislation in re contracts, construction etc is UK wide in its extent. However, rules in re contract formation et al are be subtly different.
Make sure to call out English precedents as such, probably binding in Scotland in most cases, esp where ratio bites on same statute or equivalent common law principles.
Travisfliva says:
viagra for womens where to buy does revatio work like viagra is viagra funded by government
Artrunusa says:
cialis online cheap buy brand name cialis cialis mastercard
Strokepay says:
ivermectin for cats dewormer stromectol and alcohol the drug ivermectin
Strokepay says:
ivermectin pour on ivermectin in canada ivermectin dosage for cats
Edwardgof says:
cialis canadian pharmacy no prescription canadian no prescription pharmacy cialis is it legal to buy cialis online?
Edwardgof says:
cialis and viagra taken together buy cialis online australia cialis buy on line
FrankEvons says:
medicine clomid 50mg clomid for sale cheap where can you buy clomid online
FrankEvons says:
prednisone 5 50mg tablet price prednisone in mexico prednisone 30 mg coupon
FrankEvons says:
buying amoxicillin in mexico amoxicillin 875 125 mg tab purchase amoxicillin 500 mg
FrankEvons says:
200 mg prednisone daily cost of prednisone in canada prednisone for cheap
FrankEvons says:
cost of amoxicillin prescription amoxicillin 500 mg tablet price where can you get amoxicillin
FrankEvons says:
doxycycline hyclate 100 mg capsules doxycycline tablets for sale doxycycline price 100mg
FrankEvons says:
how to get amoxicillin over the counter amoxil generic how to buy amoxicillin online
HaroldSof says:
buy medication online ed help buy online pharmacy
HaroldSof says:
help with ed overcoming ed best ed medication
HaroldSof says:
ed clinic medication drugs is it illegal to buy prescription drugs online
HaroldSof says:
ed problems treatment male ed best price for generic viagra on the internet
HaroldSof says:
anti fungal pills without prescription best medication for ed erectile dysfunction treatment
StacyIdeop says:
ivermectin virus ivermectin protocol pour on ivermectin for chickens
StacyIdeop says:
prednisone 20 mg tablets how to buy prednisone online can you buy prednisone
StacyIdeop says:
does cialis really work purchase original cialis cialis dosage vs viagra
StacyIdeop says:
pharmacy cialis no prescription health plus cialis cialis discounts
StacyIdeop says:
can cialis cause high blood pressure buy cialis via pay pal cialis for sale in toront ontario
CharlesDaw says:
ivermectin horse paste for rosacea ivermectin ebay
Jamesamaky says:
male dysfunction treatment prescription drugs online without doctor mens ed
Jamesamaky says:
sexual dysfunction in men best male enhancement pills natural ed pills
Jamesamaky says:
where to get prednisone cheap prednisone prednisone online india
Jamesamaky says:
prednisone for sale online buy prednisone prednisone 2.5 mg price
Jamesamaky says:
how to buy generic cialis online cialis pills cialis with dapoxetine for sale
Jamesamaky says:
ivermectin 50 mg ivermectin over the counter uk antiparasitic drugs ivermectin
Jamesamaky says:
cialischeap cialis pills buy cialis canada
GregoryLeave says:
cheap erectile dysfunction pill best erectile dysfunction pills non prescription ed pills
GregoryLeave says:
natural ed medications treatments for ed top ed pills
GregoryLeave says:
ed pills that work best ed treatment erection pills online
GregoryLeave says:
natural ed medications non prescription erection pills best erectile dysfunction pills
GregoryLeave says:
petco ivermectin ivermectin dosage for sheep ivermectin heartworms
GregoryLeave says:
propecia prescription mail order propecia finasteride cost
GregoryLeave says:
prescription drugs without prior prescription non prescription erection pills buy prescription drugs
Stromsella says:
top rated canadian pharmacies online discount prescription drugs online buying from canadian online pharmacies
Stromsella says:
top rated canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacy certified canada pharmacy online pharmacy without dr prescriptions
Stromsella says:
stromectol price usa stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol 12 mg tablets
tlluhnda says:
order modafinil for sale
brbpkaow says:
buy modafinil 100mg pills
pqnpsjkx says:
modafinil brand modafinil pill
qygkglfb says:
provigil medication
DouglasIndes says:
viagra sildenafil 20 mg sildenafil citrate tablets 100 mg
shyvtgbw says:
modafinil tablet purchase provigil pill
seolmwkh says:
erythromycin benzoyl peroxide topical gel http://erythromycinn.com/#
DouglasIndes says:
sildenafil citrate tablets 100 mg price for viagra viagra tablets for men
DouglasIndes says:
cialis from india cialis coupon online purchase of tadalafil in india
yimqmmpj says:
modafinil us provigil 200mg for sale
ibkrjlip says:
brand modafinil 100mg