Categories
Uncategorized

Review a journal publication in the field of combustion or on a combustion application.

MMAE 524 Project 1
Description: Review a journal publication in the field of combustion or on a combustion application.
Choose a topic of interest to you but the paper should not be in an area you are already doing research.
Your final written report should include:
1) an overview of the paper you reviewed (What is the big picture of what they did and why?)
2) a discussion on the main findings and any shortcomings of the paper (What did they find and are
they missing anything?)
3) a proposal as to what you feel the authors should consider for future work based on their
findings (What should be studied next?)
Scoring Breakdown Points
Possible
Points
Awarded
Overview 20: complete overview of study and its importance
10: major omissions (significant factors left out)
20
Discussion of
Main Findings
and Shortcomings
60: thorough discussion of what was studied and
shortcomings
40: basic discussion on both study and shortcomings
but lacking depth of understanding
20: errors in understanding of study and
shortcomings
60
Proposal of
Needed Future
Work
20: insightful discussion that shows a clear
understanding of the area
10: some discussion but focuses on more obvious
barriers
20
Total: /100

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *